Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

New Paychex Data Shows Independent Contractor Growth Outpaces Employee Hiring in Small Businesses

January 09, 2019

Independent contractors graph

Small business owners are increasingly relying on the services of independent contractors as an integral part of their business. According to new research released today by Paychex, Inc., the growth rate of independent contractors peaked in August 2017 at 11 percent year-over-year, and while the growth has slowed since then (five percent in August 2018), it far outpaces the growth rate for employee hiring among small businesses, which has been at less than one percent since 2013 for businesses with 1-49 employees and at least one independent contractor.

According to the IRS, generally, a worker is classified as an independent contractor for tax purposes if the payer (or business) has the right to control or direct only the result of the work and not what will be done and how it will be done. As such, the earnings of a person who is working as an independent contractor are subject to self-employment tax.

Among small businesses that utilize independent contractors, the data shows that the rate of growth for independent contractors has been faster than employees for the past five years. Broken down by business size, gender, geography, and industry, data highlights include:

Business Size
Businesses with one to four employees utilize the most independent contractors (6.7 per employer).

There is a slightly higher percentage of male independent contractors (51 percent nationally), but the percentage of female independent contractors is on the rise, increasing 1.5 percent during the past five years.

The South has the highest percentage of small businesses with independent contract workers among regions (38 percent) and the Northeast has the lowest percentage (26 percent).

In Texas, total worker growth slowed at businesses that utilize independent contractors from the middle of 2016 through 2017. When it increased once again, it was led by independent contractor growth, which averaged 33 percent of total workers in 2016 through 2017, and 37 percent in 2018.

Independent contractors have driven worker growth in Miami, especially during the past five years. Among small businesses that utilize independent contractors in Miami, independent contractors make up 47 percent of total workers, compared to a national average of 36 percent.

Industry Sector 
Trade, Transportation, and Utilities use the most independent contractors among industries, while Manufacturing uses the fewest.

“Businesses of every age, industry, and geography are relying on the services of independent contractors as well as employees to help run their organizations,” said Martin Mucci, Paychex president and CEO. “The more types of workers you have though, the more complex compliance becomes, so business owners should work with their payroll and HR provider, or other trusted business advisor, to make sure they have a strong understanding of how applicable laws define worker status.”

For Larry Davenport of MIT Group, Oklahoma City, engaging the services of independent contractors has had its benefits. “We use independent IT contractors when possible, as they typically have the skill sets and the industry expertise we need to fulfill our projects… Our projects are short-term and unless there are follow-on projects using the same skill sets, they (employees) sit on the bench and draw income from the company, which could be better spent elsewhere,” said Davenport.

As the use of independent contractors increases across the U.S., states – including California, Illinois, and New Jersey – and courts are actively examining worker classification definitions, with the aim of advancing potentially greater worker protections.

To view an infographic featuring key data points from this analysis of independent contractor growth, visit

About the Independent Contractor Infographic   
The data included in the “Independent Contractors are Changing the Business Landscape” infographic was taken from a historical analysis of a subset of Paychex clients, with 1-49 employees and at least one independent contractor (filed as a 1099-MISC), comparing the rate of growth for independent contractors vs. employees from May 2010 through August 2018.

About Paychex
Paychex, Inc. (NASDAQ: PAYX) is a leading provider of integrated human capital management solutions for payroll, benefits, human resources, and insurance services. By combining its innovative software-as-a-service technology and mobility platform with dedicated, personal service, Paychex empowers small- and medium-sized business owners to focus on the growth and management of their business. Backed by more than 45 years of industry expertise, Paychex serves over 650,000 payroll clients as of May 31, 2018, across more than 100 locations in the U.S. and Europe, and pays one out of every 12 American private sector employees. Learn more about Paychex by visiting, and stay connected on Twitter and LinkedIn.